Press "Enter" to skip to content

A Commentary on Jean-Paul Sartre's Critique of Dialectical by Joseph S. Catalano

By Joseph S. Catalano

Sartre’s Critique of Dialectical cause ranks with Being and Nothingness as a piece of significant philosophical importance, however it has been principally missed. the 1st quantity, released in 1960, was once brushed off as a Marxist paintings at a time whilst structuralism used to be getting into fashion; the unfinished moment quantity has just recently been released in France. during this observation at the first quantity, Joseph S. Catalano restores the Critique to its deserved position between Sartre’s works and inside philosophical discourse as a complete. Sartre
attempts the most wanted projects of our instances, Catalano asserts—the supply of historical past into the palms of the typical person.

Sartre’s difficulty within the Critique is with the historic value of way of life. will we, he asks, as participants or perhaps jointly, direct the process our background? A historic context for our lives is given to us at delivery, yet we maintain that context with even our so much mundane actions—buying a newspaper, ready in line, consuming a meal. In historical past, Sartre argues, cause can by no means separate the ancient state of affairs of the investigator from the research. hence cause falls right into a dialectic, constantly based upon the previous for information yet continuously being reshaped by means of the present.

Clearly displaying the impact of Marx on Sartre’s inspiration, the Critique provides the historic measurement missing in Being and Nothingness. In putting the Critique in the corpus of Sartre’s philosophical writings, Catalano argues that it represents a improvement instead of a holiday from Sartre’s existentialist part. Catalano has equipped his statement to stick with the Critique and has provided transparent examples and urban expositions of the main tough rules. He explicates the discussion among Marx and Sartre that's inner to the textual content, and he additionally discusses Sartre’s look for technique, that is released individually from the Critique in English variations.

Show description

Read or Download A Commentary on Jean-Paul Sartre's Critique of Dialectical Reason, Volume 1, Theory of Practical Ensembles PDF

Similar philosophy books

The Work of Sartre: Search for Freedom and the Challenge of History

This landmark booklet, first released in 1979, met acclaim as a doubly very important paintings of radical philosophy. Its topic, Jean-Paul Sartre, used to be one of the 20th century's so much arguable and influential philosophers; its writer, István Mészáros, was once himself developing a name for profound contributions to the Marxian culture, which might proceed into the following century.

Plato's Parmenides Reconsidered

Parmenides is especially typically learn as a turning aspect in Plato's philosophical improvement. such a lot students assert that, in Parmenides, Plato heavily criticizes his idea of varieties. in response to a few proponents of this stance, Plato later got here to view his personal criticisms as altogether too harmful and therefore as a consequence deserted his conception of kinds.


Almagestes se rapportait essentiellement au Langage. Portulans concerne los angeles Subjectivité - mieux vaudrait dire les figurations romanesques de cette building idéologique particulière que depuis deux ou trois siècles on appelle : sujet, personne, individu, judgment of right and wrong, et au dépérissement de laquelle nous avons le bonheur ambigu d'assister.

Der Mensch und die Technik; Beitrag zu einer Philosophie des Lebens

Oswald Spengler: Der Mensch und die Technik. Beitrag zu einer Philosophie des Lebens variation Holzinger. Taschenbuch Berliner Ausgabe, 2016, four. Auflage Durchgesehener Neusatz bearbeitet und eingerichtet von Michael Holzinger Erstdruck: München: Beck, 1931. Textgrundlage ist die Ausgabe: Oswald Spengler: Der Mensch und die Technik.

Additional resources for A Commentary on Jean-Paul Sartre's Critique of Dialectical Reason, Volume 1, Theory of Practical Ensembles

Example text

17. For a different exposition of the preceding three works, see Thomas R. Flynn, Sartre and Marxist Existentialism (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984), 43, 53, 78-80; Peter Caws, Sartre (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1979), 131-43; and Ronald Aronson, Jean-Paul Sartre (London: New Left Books and Verso, 1980), 214-33. See also Perry Anderson, In the Tracts of Historical Materialism (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1984), 69-73. Anderson remarks: "The Ghost of Stalin, which in and through its very excoriation of the Russian intervention in Hungary, held firm to the prediction that 'deStalinization will deStalinize the deStalinizers'" (71).

Some men, by placing themselves in a certain political perspective, based on an evaluation which is their own of the international relations, judged it preferable to refuse the socialist forces of the new Hungary their chances and to plunge this country into chaos" (Ghost, 63 [Sartre's italics]). And, a little further on, he adds: Born of the Plan, it is the Plan which legitimizes their privileges: their personal ambition is not distinct from their devotion to socialism conceived as abstract economic planning, that is to say, ultimately, as the continuous increase of production.

But the fault was not only with Stalin but also with those who followed him. Here again, Sartre refuses to be merely deterministic. As he is to repeat frequently, history makes humans, but humans also make history. Sartre concludes by turning his attention to the Party in France. 17 For our part, it's been twelve years that we have been debating with the Communists. At first with violence, later in friendship. But our goal was always the same: to cooperate with our feeble forces in achieving this union of the Lefts which alone can still save our country.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.35 of 5 – based on 20 votes